Describing Racist or Racialised Actions Using the Declarative Mapping Sentence Method

Résumé

In the US and many other countries, when we watch or read the news reports seem to demonstrate that there is an endless stream of racially motivated hateful behaviours and expressions. These are so common place that they may not make front page news. The physical attack upon, and murder of George Floyd in Minneapolis and the verbal attack on Christian Cooper in Central Park, New York City, both in May 2020, were exceptions that made the news headlines around the world. The prosecution of Floyd's killer, a serving police officer, demonstrated the increased prominence of racialised events that has resulted in raised awareness of racism in many communities. The above two incidents also show that racially motivated behaviours may be of very different kinds and forms.Racism may also constitute a set of beliefs that embodies the notion that the social construct of races exist and that people from different races have divergent and separately identifiable qualities, characteristics, skills and abilities. Racism can take the form of prejudice, discrimination, or antagonism as this is expresses by individual's, institutions or even communities and nations. Racism may be targeted towards an individual person or a group of people due to their membership of specific racial or ethnic group that usually possesses a marginalised or minority position in a society. Furthermore, the characteristics that a marginalised race is believed to possess are often used to identify such individuals as being inferior in relation to members of the race who are attributing such depreciatory characteristics.Racism and racist acts are deeply repugnant and are disparaged by much of society. However, some of these behaviours and beliefs may be thought of as racialized rather than being expressly racist in that they may not be designed or intended to be negative towards a specific group, but even without this intention this is the consequence. Very often, the White establishment has largely ignored many of these institutional and social situations whilst concentrating upon the necessary and essential first-step of prohibiting racially abusive language and overtly racist acts. An example of this can be seen in the effects of Covid-19 within the US which has impacted upon minority communities much harder than white communities. Being a person of colour in the US has always been associated with a health status that is typically worse than that of white people and people of colour have poorer health as measured along a series of measures. Gould and Wilson (2020) note how during the pandemic there has been a high level of association between being black and high incidences of Covid-19: "Black workers face the two most lethal preexisting conditions for coronavirus -racism and economic inequality. …..Black Americans make up 12.5% of the US population but account for 22.4% of COVID-19 deaths" Gould and Wilson (2020).Being black has many other consequences. For instance, in the US, black individuals and other non-white people have a vastly higher probability of being stopped when driving by the police than do white drivers. There is also a very large and disproportionate number of people of colour in US prisons and even more disturbingly, African Americans are nearly three times more likely to be killed by a police officer than whites individuals (Economist, 2020). In terms of employment, many of the jobs that white people do not want to do are occupied by people of colour and they are often paid less than the white who do the same type of work.As I noted elsewhere (Hackett, 2020a) being white has afforded me many privileges that I often am not even aware of. For example, Christian Cooper was a bird watcher who was subject to a verbal racial attack whilst he was watching birds in Central Park, New York, last year (see, Axelson, 2020;Mock, 2020). I have watched birds in locations across the world and "occasionally I have) felt conspicuous when using his binoculars and even nervous about how he may be perceived by others". I gave the example of birdwatching in communist Eastern Europe as being a time when I was wary. When I have watched birds in Central Park I have felt a little apprehensive due to the fact that I constitute an unusual sight. However: "In Central Park, (I have) never been afraid of being labeled a White man; a person who is "not of color".". In this and other situations my color is transparent. I have no color. I am just a male birdwatcher. However, Christian Cooper was labelled an African American male by an irate dog owner and even though this is a politically correct epithet it was used to describe Cooper to the police it labelled him with a term of difference, a term of racial abuse.The preceding paragraphs constitute an extremely selective and brief reflection upon racism in contemporary US society. Obviously, the examples of racism are broader, more varied and wider ranging then those I have given. Above, I have, on a few occasions, used the term racialized as it avoids the ascription of intent to an activity or event that has negative outcomes for people of colour or of a minority race. This is important as it avoids having to determine whether an action was committed with an intended racial outcome. A racialized event or action is simply one that differentiates on a colour, racial or minority basis and typically has a negative outcome for members of these groups.With this in mind, the aim of in this brief paper is to present a framework for describing racist or racialised expressions using the declarative mapping sentence method: an approach which embodies the complexity of racism and offers a tool for designing research into different forms of racism and racialized events. The declarative mapping sentence method has been employed in several research contexts (e.g., Hackett, 2020a&b, 2021 as a framework within which qualitative research may be designed and conducted. It is both an inductive and deductive approach as it provides a flexible and responsive framework for research whilst being constantly updated based upon the experiences of the researcher. Below I propose a declarative mapping sentence (DMS) that is an adaptation of earlier research (Hackett and Schwarzenbach, 2020) which attempts to provide a framework for understanding and defining racist and racialized acts (figure 1). This framework may be used to design and interpret research in this area. Employing the DMS in the development of a research project enables the inclusion the important aspects of such acts within the research. There are six facets in this declarative mapping sentence for understanding acts of racism (written in the right column). These are: mode of person viewing, type of action/event, mode of expression, intent, target, consequence. To the left of each of these six facets are written their respective elements.The DMS states that racist acts are committed by people, either individually or in groups. The sentence specifies that such an act may be thought of in terms of the type of action committed which are specified as being verbal, physical, or acts that are a mixture of these. The DMS then denotes that it is important to consider the intention behind such an action, which may be intentional, unintentional, or unthinking. Who is the action targeted against is of importance and in the DMS the targets may be individual, specific groups, or wider culture groups. The consequence of the action is also important to keep in mind when designing and interpreting research: I suggest the elements of death, physical injury, psychological injury, a mixture of these, and social segregation/unrest. It is also noted that the person who is viewing and interpreting the action is an important component of the research in terms of whether they are Black or not Black. It is my contention that it is important to consider these aspects of the situation when designing or interpreting a piece of qualitative research into racism.The DMS may be used as a design template and a coding frame. When using this as a designing tool observations and questions are developed based upon elements from all of the facets combined in a manner suggested by in the DMS. This allows the researcher to be assured that all of the pertinent aspects of the research area are included in their inquiries. When used as coding frame during thematic content analysis, the elements of the mapping sentence are used in a researcher's first attempt at coding a specific data set. Schreier (2012) suggests that coding should be undertaken using 3 attempts of ever greater finesse. When using the declarative mapping sentence to code data the elements are observed for on the first reading and then modified on the subsequent two rounds of coding and as the codes become more concrete and contextualized, so the elements of the mapping sentence are deleted, added to and amended.

Citer ce document

Accès au document

Ce document est hébergé sur son dépôt institutionnel d'origine.

Auteur(s)

Statistiques

Consultations : 1

Téléchargements : 0